Build a Syracuse team using 1919-1920 rules

 The rules of college basketball have changed dramatically over the years. In many ways the game we play today is very different from the game Dr. James Naismith invented in 1892. The game did not suddenly change, but rather slowly evolved over time.

These were some of the rules differing from today for college basketball in the 1919-1920 season:

• Any player on the court can take the free throw, not just the player who was fouled
• There was no charging foul
• There was a jump ball after every made basket
• There is no shot clock, nor no 10 second mid-court violation
• There is no three second lane violation
• A player may not re-enter the game
• Coaches are not permitted to speak to players during the game
• A jump ball exists after every held ball
• There is no three point basket
• Traveling is a foul, not just a violation
• Players are disqualified after 4 fouls
• No Euro-step is permitted

Given these are the rules, what would be your all-time Syracuse squad to play in those conditions? Who are your starting five, and who are on your bench (we'll stick to 13 man roster if you want to have the complete roster).

I am definitely going to want some free throw shooters, and one needs to be on the court at all times. Fortunately poor shooting big men won’t matter, so guys like Rony Seikaly, Arinze Onuaku, and Stephen Thompson suddenly become more valuable.

I’m definitely have Gerry McNamara on my starting five, and Jimmy Lee and Greg Kohls off my bench in the event GMac ever fouls out or gets hurt.

Derrick Coleman is my starting center. He can camp out in the paint, and his low post moves and size would be tremendous. Plus he is a solid shot blocker, and with no goal tending restriction that would be amazing. And he is going to help a lot with the frequent jump balls. Rony Seikaly, Etan Thomas, and Roosevelt Bouie come off my bench. I’m going deep with centers off the bench because of possible foul problems.

You aren’t going to need three point shooters, but you are going to need mid range and perimeter shooters as the paint is going to be very crowded.

Carmelo Anthony is a no brainer, and I’ll add Billy Owens to the other wing. With Coleman, Anthony and Owens on the court, I’m going to have no problem bringing the ball up the court.

The impeccable Dave Bing is going to run the point for my team. I do want guys who can get the ball to the low post, so on the bench I'll have Sherman Douglas. I think his alley oop passes are a way to get around the openness on goaltending. With goal tending not being a rule, guys like the Pearl may have a bit tougher time.

I also think guys who have a strong low post game with a lot of dunking ability will thrive. So I’ve got to put Hakim Warrick on the squad, coming off the bench. His drop step dunk, especially with no charge calls, would be incredibly tough to stop.

And I want to fill out my roster with a great perimeter shooter who can pass the ball well. So Andy Rautins, welcome aboard.

So my squad is:

G: Dave Bing

G: Gerry McNamara

F: Carmelo Anthony

F: Billy Owens

C: Derrick Coleman

Bench

G: Greg Kohls

G: Jimmy Lee

G: Sherman Douglas

F/G: Andy Rautins

F: Hakim Warrick

C: Rony Seikaly

C: Etan Thomas

C: Roosevelt Bouie

Syracuse Player Improvements

The Orange are now 6-1 after their first seven games.  While all the games have not been pretty, I think overall as fans we are happy with that record.  The team's offense is clearly improved from what we witnessed over the past few seasons, and the defense is struggling.  

Recent history with the basketball program has been frustrating as players we hoped would make that 'leap' forward in their skill development, failed to do so.  Th

Quincy Guerrier

is season we are blessed to have several players who have shown growth or are better than we expected.

Quincy Guerrier, Alan Griffin, Kadary Richmond and Woody Newton are pleasant surprises this season.

Guerrier is leading the way with a new focus on his interior game and it is paying off big dividends for himself and the Orange.  The Buffalo game was his latest and greatest effort with 27 points and 11 rebounds.  He has been doing that all season, and quite efficiently.  Guerrier is currently averaging 18.0 ppg along with 10 rebounds per game, all done with 66% shooting from the floor and 43.8% from three.  He already has four double-doubles this season, exceeding last season's total by one.  Last year he was content on hanging out on the perimeter, and this year he is doing the hard work down low.

We knew Alan Griffin could shoot when he transferred to Syracuse from Illinois, and he had a nose for rebounding.  He has been better than advertised, with athletic availability that his paying big dividends for the Orange.  He has been erratic and inconsistent with his effort on both ends of the court.  The Northeastern game was the low water mark when he was held scoreless and seemed disinterested on both ends of the court, resulting in him not playing down the stretch of the game.  On the other hand, he has had four games where he has scored 20+ points, and three double-doubles.  The Buffalo game showed his top value to the Orange when he had 24 points and 10 rebounds, including a game saving block on a Buffalo layup as time was expiring.  And though Griffin struggled from three for the game, he made seven of eight shots inside the arc, as well as seven of eight free throws

Coach Jim Boeheim raved about Kadary Richmond in the pre-season, and the young man has looked very promising.  He is using his length, speed and ballhandling to contribute in many different ways, and has earned himself as steady part of the guard rotation.  After seven games Richmond is averaging 26 minutes a game.  He has 4.1 assists a game, along with 4.4 rebounds, 1.1 blocks, and 2.6 steals.  He is not a perimeter shooter, but has shown very adept at getting into the paint, and is making 47% of his field goal attempts.

Woody Newton was flying under the radar, and based on some comments from Jim Boeheim, I think he is playing better than even the coaches thought he would at this point.  While Newton isn't playing a lot of minutes, he is part of the 'Boeheim rotation' and gets into every game.  He's made 42% of this three point shots despite not having a reputation as being a perimeter shooter, and he has shown some athleticism on getting to the hoop.

Marek Dolezaj and Buddy Boeheim are delivering what I think we would expect, with some minor improvements.  Dolezaj has had to move over to the center position to replace the injured Bourama Sidibe. While the defense isn't as proficient with him there, the offense is benefiting greatly.  Dolezaj is being used to facilitate the offense with his playmaking, and he is showing off his ability to get to the hoop for short range shots.  Dolezaj is hitting 55% of this field goals, and leads he team with 4.3 assists.  Also importantly, he has avoided foul trouble for the most part. It is clear that when the ball flows through Dolezaj's hands, good things happen.

Buddy Boeheim missed three games and roughly a month of practice due to Covid-19 safety precautions.  It has had an impact on his shooting touch for sure. However, the junior continues to add to his offensive skills and has really made a focus on scoring within the paint.  Good things are happening when he gets inside.  Even when he does not make the shot, the defense does collapse on him, and the SU forwards are able to crash the glass and get the rebounds from the soft touch shots. Boeheim is averaging 15.5 ppg despite hitting only 26% of his three point shots.

Joe Girard and Bobby Braswell are two players who are struggling this year.  Like Boeheim, Girard's shooting touch as been off for most the games this year, and some of the competition has figured out ways of taking Girard out of his game.  He is going to have to learn to make the proper adjustments.  This year when he struggles, Coach Boeheim does have the luxury of a third guard, and he makes the player adjustments accordingly.  Girard has been rebounding well, and twice he has scored 21 points.  Syracuse likely does not beat Northeastern without Girard's six steals, four rebounds and three assists.

Bobby Braswell was thought to be a player that Boeheim was going to have to find playing time for.  Instead he has struggled on the court with rushed shots, and he has fallen behind Woody Newton on the depth chart.  

Bourama Sidibe got injured four minutes into the season opener, and has not played since. He had surgery on this knee and is expected back soon.  A healthy return would provide some big dividends to the defense, though it will be interesting on how the offensive scheme would work once he is available.  He definitely would have been of value against Rutgers and Buffalo, both teams who dominated with big mean inside the paint.

The other disappointment on the team has been the three young centers: Jesse Edwards, John Bol Ajak and Frank Anselem. Despite the need for center help, none of the three have demonstrated enough to  Coach Boeheim to get consistent playing time.  Having said that, Ajak is surprising in that the perception was that he was the biggest project of the three, and yet he is the first one off the bench when Boeheim does bring in a reserve center.  

Overall, the Orange have already provided several entertaining moments for us this season.  Some of the wins haven't been as easy or pretty as we would like, but the team is 6-1.  Hard to dislike that.

Top Competition by the Decade

The Syracuse Orange have played the Colgate Raiders 172 times, by far the most games against any other school. The series stopped being competitive in the late sixties, though I imagine some fans would be surprised to know it was still a competitive series in the Dave Bing/Jim Boeheim era. The two teams played a triple overtime game in 1965, that the Orange eventually won 93-90 behind Bing's 45 points. That was probably the end of the competitive era for the two teams; there have been the occasional close game since then, but overall, nothing too noteworthy. Colgate and Syracuse used to be the biggest rivalry on the schedule, and for the first thirty years or so, the game was often one of the last games on the schedule in order to close the season out with a big game. 

Cornell is next on the list with 125 games, and Pittsburgh is third with 118. Given that Syracuse typically plays Pitt twice a year, we can expect Pitt to overtake Cornell within 7 seasons, if not sooner. 

The top teams that Syracuse has played each decade has changed over the years. Syracuse was not in a conference until the 1979-1980 season, so prior to that their games were against a lot of Eastern schools, but no set schedule. Since 1979-1980, the Big East dictated a good portion of their schedule, and subsequently the ACC has since the Orange changed conferences. 

 I've put a list together of the top 5 teams the Orange played each decade, and you can see those results if you look at the decade information. 

 Here is the leader for each decade:

There are probably no big surprises on that list.  The 27 games against Georgetown in the eighties helps to explain the rivalry a lot. They played nineteen games during the regular season, and eight more in that decade in the Big East Tournament. When two teams meet routinely in a post season tournament, there are going to be a lot of 'big games' in your history.

Buddy Surpasses his Father

Buddy Boeheim scored 17 points today in the win over Boston College, giving him a career total of 746 points in 66 games played.  That's 11.3 ppg for his career.

Buddy and Jim Boeheim

Buddy's father Jim scored 745 points in his Syracuse career in 76 games played, for a 9.8 ppg average.

Jim Boeheim also had 177 career rebounds.  Buddy only as 115, so it may be a while until the son overtakes the father there.

Veterans Day 2020

 On this Veterans day, as I have done each year past, I would like to thank all those who have served our country, putting their lives on the line to do those tasks that need to be done. The Orange basketball team has had its share of veterans over the decades. And has been tradition at OrangeHoops, I would like to recognize those former basketball Orangemen who did serve. I acknowledge this is not a complete list; only those I know of (each year I add a few more). I imagine more Orangemen were in the service that I am omitting; if so, please post a recognition here! Also please feel free to recognize any other veterans in the comments.

In World War I, the following served:

Albert Ackley
Bradley Barnard
Ross Bibbens
Meyer Bloom
Jim Casey
Ed Cronauer
Charles Fasce
Russ Finsterwald
Loyal Greenman
Ken Harris
Ted Huntley
Bernie Kates
Ken Lavin
Nathan Malefski
Danny Martin
Harry Martin
Walter ‘Dutch’ Notman
Walter Peters
Elias Raff
Billy Rafter
Horace Ruffin
Courtland Sanney
Clifford Steele

In World War II, the following served:

Jim Ackerson
Earl Ackley
Lou Alkoff
John Baldwin (Balsavich)
John Balinsky
John Beaulieu
John Beck
Gene Berger
Milton 'Whitey' Bock
Leo Canale
Dick Casey
Larry Crandall
Wilbur Crisp
Dan DiPace
Les Dye
Bud Elford
Alton Elliott
John Emerich
Bill Estoff
Bob Felasco
Paul Ferris
Billy Gabor
Ed Glacken
Joe Glacken
Marc Guley
Mark Haller
LaVerne Hastings
Lew Hayman
Bill Hennemuth
Bill Hoeppel
Tom Huggins
George Jarvis
Ed Jontos
Walter Kiebach
Jim Konstanty
Christian Kouray
Stan Kruse (Kruszewski)

Phil Lipetz
Glenn Loucks
Guy Luciano
Saul Mariaschin
Bob Masterson
Paul McKee
Don McNaughton
Tom McTiernan
Francis Miller
Joe Minsavage
Andy Mogish
Roy Peters
Hank Piro
Paul Podbielski
Edward Pond
Robert Popp
Phil Rakov
Joe Rigan
John Schroeder
Bill Schubert
Bob Shaddock
Wilmeth Sidat-Singh
Red Stanton
Mike Stark
Chester Stearns
Bobby Stewart
Joe Sylvestri
Charles Taggart
Ray Tice
Joe Weber
Ray Willmott
Bill Wyrick

In Korea the following served:

Reaves Baysinger, Jr
John Beaulieu
Bernie Eischen
Paul McKee
Paul Podbielski
Fred Serley

Dick Suprunowicz

In Vietnam, the following served:

Reaves Baysinger, Jr
John Beaulieu
George Crofoot
Rick Dean
Sanford Salz

The following were veterans who served but were fortunate to miss a war era:

Vinnie Albanese
Art Barr
Mel Besdin
Rudy Cosentino
Roy Danforth
Ronnie Kilpatrick
George Koesters
Tom Jockle
Jack Malone
Frank Reddout
Eddie Rosen
Lou Stark
Chuck Steveskey

Five of the aforementioned players deserve special note, as they sacrificed their lives in the line of duty.

Harry Martin was killed in 1923 when his plane crashed during takeoff at Kelley Field, Texas.  He was a Lieutenant and an Army Aviator.  Martin had served in the AEF in France in World War I.

Wilmeth Sidat-Singh was a member of the Tuskegee Airman, and was killed in a training accident when his plane crashed into Lake Michigan in 1943.

Joe Minsavage was killed in World War II on June 19, 1943 when his ship was attacked and he was lost at sea.

Charles Taggart was a member of the US Navy serving aboard the USS Frederick C. Davis, and was killed when his ship was torpedoed by a German U-Boat on April 24, 1945. Taggart and 115 crew members perished.

Gene Berger was killed in 1961 during flight maneuvers. He was a Commander in the U.S. Navy and a Naval aviator, and his plane would crash into the Pacific.

A Center Wish List

Syracuse fans have been clamoring for the Orange to get a strong center, someone who can score in the low post, rebound, and play defense.  Not necessarily a superstar, but someone who was fundamentally sound.

How about if I got you a 6'10" center, about 215 lbs, who averages 11.7 rebounds per game, and makes 70% of his field goals.   He shoots 63% from the charity stripe, which isn't earth shattering, but is better than many SU centers of the past.   He averages 9.8 points a game, 2.7 blocks, and 2.4 stores, while only turning over the ball 1 time each game?

I imagine that is a center that most Syracuse fans would jump at.

Well then welcome Bourama Sidibe.  Those were Sidibe's stats the last six games of his junior season.  That included two games against North Carolina, and games against Miami, Boston College, Pitt, and Georgia Tech. 

It will be interesting to see if Sidibe can carry that momentum forward into 2020-2021. One of his biggest problems historically has been avoiding fouls. That more than anything has limited his effectiveness, often keeping him at less than 25 minutes a game (he averaged 23.9 minutes a game for the season).  Sidibe fouled out of 14 games last year, definitely an issue.  During the six game stretch to finish the season, he averaged 29.2 minutes a game, and twice played 35 minutes.

Sidibe did shoot 69% from the floor for the season, and averaged 7.9 rebounds a game despite playing less than 24 minutes a game.

All in the Family

The 2020-2021 Syracuse Orange basketball team will feature five players with family connections to the basketball program.

The most casual fans are aware that starting shooting guard Buddy Boeheim is the son of Syracuse head coach Jim Boeheim.  Jim scored 745 points in his Syracuse career. Buddy will surpass him fairly early this season as he is currently at 708 points.

Walk-on forward Nick Giancola is Jim Boeheim's nephew, the son of his wife Juli's sister, and Buddy's cousin.  Nick played in five games last season, but has yet to score for the Orange.  

Walk-on guard Shane Feldman is the younger brother of current graduate assistant and former walk-on guard Ky Feldman.  Ky scored 10 points in his Syracuse career; Shane has yet to play.

Walk-on forward Chaz Owens is the son of all-time Syracuse great Billy Owens.  Billy Owens was the Big East Player of the Year his junior year, and had a solid NBA career. Billy scored 1,840 points in his three years at Syracuse, while Chaz has yet to play.

Finally, walk-on guard Chris Lavalle is the son of Kelly LaValle-Seubert, who was the long time administrative assistant to head coach Jim Boeheim.  Kelly passed away due to cancer in 2017, and the school named the players' lounge after her.  Lavalle played in five games last year, but failed to score in any.