We often hear about Syracuse playing local schools, and they
do have a storied history regarding playing teams from New York state. Since 1900, the Orange have played 46
different New York teams, with Colgate well established at the top.
Here is a list of all 46 teams, what the Orange’s record is
against that team and how many games they have played.
1. Colgate 126-45, 171 games
2. Cornell 93-31, 124 games
3. St. John’s 51-40, 91 games
4. Niagara 53-28, 81 games
5. Canisius 46-24, 70 games
6. Rochester 53-11, 64 games
7. Fordham 28-16, 44 games
8. Buffalo 28-6, 34 games
9. St. Lawrence 26-8, 34 games
10. Army 19-11, 30 games
11. St. Bonaventure 25-4, 29 games
12. Manhattan 21-7, 28 games
13. NYU 9-12, 21 games
14. Clarkson 17-1, 18 games
15. RPI 13-5, 18 games
16. Union 15-3, 18 games
17. Columbia 11-3, 14 games
18. CCNY 5-8, 13 games
19. Hobart 11-0, 11 games
20. Albany 8-0, 8 games
21. Alfred 8-0, 8 games
22. Siena 8-0, 8 games
23. Hamilton 6-1, 7 games
24. LeMoyne 6-0, 6 games
25. Binghamton 5-0, 5 games
26. Iona 5-0, 5 games
27. Sampson Naval Training 3-2, 5 games
28. Buffalo State 4-0, 4 games
29. Cortland State 4-0, 4 games
30. Oswego State 3-1, 4 games
31. Potsdam 4-0, 4 games
32. St Francis College 4-0, 4 games
33. Utica 4-0, 4 games
34. CW Post 3-0, 3 games
35. Hofstra 3-0, 3 games
36. Ithaca College 3-0, 3 games
37. Wagner 3-0, 3 games
39. Queens College 2-0, 2 games
39. Schenectady Company E 0-2, 2 games
40. Syracuse All-Stars 1-0, 1 game
41. Batavia YMCA 1-0, 1 game
42. Brooklyn College 1-0, 1 game
43. Brooklyn Polytechnic 1-0, 1 game
44. Cazenovia College 1-0, 1 game
45. Long Island University 1-0, 1 game
46. NY State Teachers College 1-0, 1 game
Hobart gets the distinction of the most games against the
Orange without the Orange losing a game, a perfect 11-0.
Colgate has won more games against Syracuse than any other
New York team. Of course, 45 wins in 171
attempts isn’t very impressive, but hey, they hold the record.
NYU (9-12), CCNY (5-8), and Schenectady Company E (0-2) get
the distinction of being the only New York teams with a winning record against Syracuse.
If we want to see the top 10 New York teams that Jim Boeheim
has coached against (1976-1977 season to present), then we have:
1. St. John’s 65 games
2. Colgate 32 games
3. Cornell 32 games
4. St. Bonaventure 24 games
5. Canisius 20 games
6. Siena 8 games
7. Niagara 7 games
8. Fordham 7 games
9. Buffalo 7 games
10. Albany 7 games
St. Bonaventure moves up the list from 11th to 4th. Several teams in the top 10 all-time dropped
off. Surprisingly, only 5 NY schools routinely
played Syracuse during Jim Boeheim’s 43 year coaching career.